Means-Plus-Function: The Achilles’ Heel
Noah Systems, Inc. v. Intuit, Inc. April 9, 2012 Panel: Rader, O’Malley and Reyna. Opinion by Judge O’Malley Summary This decision illustrates that a patent could become invalidated even after...
View ArticleInstruction from PTO on Software Composition Claims
Ex parte Mewherter, 2012-007962 (PTAB, 2013) The Patent Office rarely designates decisions of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board as being “precedential,” but when it does, practitioners take note. The...
View ArticlePTAB Finally Considers “Processor” As Clearly Structure
Ex Parte Cutlip June 2, 2014 Panel: Lorin, Mohanty and Hoffman. Summary: After the debacle of three March 2013 PTAB decisions by a five judge PTAB panel relying on a strange American Heritage...
View ArticlePractical Points From The Supreme Court’s Alice Decision
Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l June 19, 2014 Summary: The Supreme Court’s Alice decision does not eliminate software patents as per se ineligible subject matter under 35 USC §101. The Court confirms...
View ArticleSurviving Alice Gone Wild
Before the Supreme Court’s decision in Alice Corp. v CLS Bank Int’l [1], Judge Moore said “this case is the death of hundreds of thousands of patents, including all business method, financial system,...
View ArticleThe fate of Software inventions related to information processing
Content Extraction and Transmission LLC v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. et al. December 23, 2014 Panel: Chen, Dyk and Taranto. Opinion by Chen. Summary The Federal Circuit held that the claims of the...
View ArticleThere is a Standing to Defend Your Expired Patent Even If an Infringement...
Sony Corp. v. Iancu Summary: The CAFC vacated the PTAB’s decision, in which the PTAB found that the limitation “reproducing means” is not computer-implemented and does not require an algorithm because...
View Article